4

Recently we are seeing lots of self answered questions (like this) where asker is posting both the question and the answer almost simultaneously.

It can very well be that the question is a duplicate of another one.

But before the question will be closed an answer to it is already present. I guess answering duplicate questions is discouraged here. But here answer is already present. So we can do nothing to stop an answer from being posted. So how to deal with this situation? Or no need to be worried at all?

EDIT:

ADD to that - Self answered off-topic questions... It seems we are also getting a lot of even off-topic questions which are self answered.. So, again, we are not getting a chance of closing (before an answer is posted).

5
  • 7
    If a user is posting several self answered but duplicate questions (i.e repeatedly posting such Q/A) then we need to explain him/her that this is not a good idea/practice. If it's just an instance that user may missed finding existing question, it may be ok to close vote and move on.
    – Pandya Mod
    Jan 16 '19 at 17:28
  • 2
    I think it is getting repetitive .. Another Q by the usr is " Can Hindus marry foreigners?" if we look closely this Q basically is asking "which castes will foreigners belong to?" and thr are Qs like that already... Yet another one is " Is the son of a Brahmin a Brahmin?" which is basically the same as asking "Is caste determined by birth or something else like Guna?" and we hv such Qs already .. So I think someone needs to talk to OP regarding this issue..@Pandya
    – Rickross
    Jan 17 '19 at 6:26
  • 2
    @Pandya But I don't think that OP has hidden agenda or something at all .. I think he is reading few verses of a text and asking a Q based on that ... He is not aware of whether the Q/As he is posting are at all new discussions or not ... so, I think it's just that someone needs to convey him this message..
    – Rickross
    Jan 17 '19 at 6:30
  • @Pandya If it was the issue of only one instance I would not hv posted a Meta .. I already foresaw the problem to be persistent & that's why posted .. now as u can see there is no stopping that trend .. even absurd off-topic Qs are getting self-answered...
    – Rickross
    Jan 31 '19 at 6:44
  • Why should we want to discourage self-answering. That is a SE feature for a reason (so when we discover something new we call tell people about it by asking and the self-answering, for example) Dec 2 '19 at 14:11
1

Self answers are welcome here. There is no problem in answering your own questions at the time of posting the question. People tend to post self answers in order to share their knowledge they have found through research. They feel enthusiastic and post a self answer. In this process, we see many duplicate questions. Is this a problem? Yes, it is a problem.

Posting self answer to duplicate questions is not different from posting duplicate questions or posting answers to duplicate questions. The problem is same at the core. Because the system shows the same suggestions even if we are just posting questions or answers along with it. In both the cases, there is a similar pattern in users - Not searching on the site before posting the question. So, the question should be How to discourage users to post answers to duplicate questions?.

When someone starts writing title or body of questions, the system will show related questions which are already asked on the same topic. By experience, I can say this search is accurate than the system search for finding duplicates. If we go through all the suggestions we are shown, it is easy to find the original and then answer the existing question.

enter image description here

Before posting a question (or answering your question like Q&A question), you are recommended to search if the question is already asked. The suggestion shows you many related questions. Also some related questions in the right hand side bar while writing body for some time. Besides this, you may go for search bar and type based on operators. This will definitely prevent duplicate questions.

The answer is already posted along with question. What can we do?

If the questions are exactly duplicates and also the wording is nearly identical, moderators may perform a merge. We should first vote to close as duplicate and then request for a merge through flagging. But we can't guarantee a merge in all the cases where there are exact duplicates. This is only done in a few cases. In these cases, there are a few points to consider.

  • If the new duplicate question has valuable information in the form of answers

  • If the wording of the both the questions is identical

There are many exact duplicates but these are not merged because they do not meet the above criteria. The intent of the question will be same but the terms and words used in the question will be different. This is the case which you have linked in the question. In the above case, the wording of new duplicate is a bit different than the target question but the intent is same. In these cases,

  • leave a comment explaining why asking and answering questions is not useful. Then vote to close it as a duplicate.

  • we can ask the user who posted in Q&A to search before question is posted.

  • If the answers are not repetitive, we can request the user to delete the answer and post it near the original before it is too late i.e., Q&A are highly upvoted.

As I said in the comment under this question I am answering, (now deleted due to unknown reasons), there are some people who do not take consider close voting or moderation seriously and only concentrate on contributing through answering. Some do not agree with the duplicate closures and answer duplicate questions in spite of duplicate comments under the question or off-topic votes on the questions. It is a bit difficult to make them understand answering duplicates is discouraged. We can only do two things. 1. Say once or twice and leave it to them. 2. Try, try and try. They will understand some day. (This path is difficult because you may receive some not good comments).

If the posted question is off-topic, close it and downvote both question and answer. Answering off-topic questions is also discouraged. Question closure has nothing to do with presence of answers. We can close a question even if there are answers under it. It stops more answers posted to it. After a few days, we will see a delete option. Then we can delete both question and answer.

In short, it is a matter of self moderation and voting. Let the users (who is posting such questions) know what is the problem and use your votes wisely. Act fast, close and delete off-topic question

0

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .