I have been going through the unanswered questions list of this SE and was surprised to see how many of the questions were actually answered in the comments. The commentator then virtually abandons the question and it kindof stays forever unsolved. Why do they not simply post it as an answer?

Alright yes, maybe they wanted it to be more detailed. So would it be a good practice to take one these perfectly good comments (maybe add a point or two) and post it as your own answer?

| |
  • Possible duplicate of Should the comments which attempt to answer questions be flagged for deletion?, particularly the answer by Pandya: "If you can expand it into an answer (i.e can post an answer from the comment), do it! It's fine; refer MSE posts suggesting that. What should be done with questions that have been self-resolved as a comment instead of an answer? [...]" – Andrew T. Jan 9 '19 at 5:03
  • 2
    "these perfectly good comments" -- it is not clear at all whether the comments are really "good" .. those are just opinions of the concerned users as long as not supported by a scriptural quote.. It's only because those users did not hv their back up sources that they have posted a comment.. If they had proper sources they would have posted an answer instead.. – Rickross Jan 9 '19 at 6:01
  • @Rickross Just out of curiosity, where do you all find your sources? Is it online or do you have copy of scriptures at home? – Macindows Jan 9 '19 at 16:31
  • 1
    Yes I hv bought many books and besides that I carry with me many resources like Manu Smriti and other Smritis and certain other scriptures which are very handy for answering... These PDFs I hv downloaded from internet.. Not all of them were downloaded from a particular site but from any site where that particular text was available at the time I was searching .. Archive.org is good place if u want to download some scriptures.. @Macindows – Rickross Jan 10 '19 at 6:32

Yes, go ahead.

It is a bad practice to write answers in comments. It's discouraged. Many users fail to understand the difference between a comment and an answer. Some think comments are for answers without citations. Some are lazy to write an answer due to their own reasons. You can use answers posted in comments, add some references to back up, expand it to a detailed answer. This really helps the answered stats. If you are just reproducing them, add attribution to author of the comment. If you are using information, then rephrase it in your own words.

Example: Hamsa Sandesha - a real incident or a fictional work?, my answer and comment underneath the question. I have answered some questions which are answered in comments and flagged the comment as "It's No longer needed". Flags were also approved.

Note of caution: As you do not have enough reputation to look at deleted answers, here is only thing you can miss. Sometimes moderators convert answers to comments. So, there could be a chance of posting the same deleted answer again. Hence, add your information found through research and add it to the answer comment.

| |

Why don't they simply post it as an answer?

Because this site has very strict standards for answers. We have the Back It Up! Rule. Wikipedia- and blog-based answers are discouraged. Writing quality answers takes time. So some people find it more convenient to write unsourced answers as comments. But this isn't a good practice.

So would it be a good practice to take one of these perfectly good comments (maybe add a point or two) and post it as your own answer?

Yes, but you need to follow the guidelines for your answer to be accepted by the community. If the (unsourced) comment is copied and posted as an answer without any additional references, then it can attract a citation banner, a few downvotes and then eventually deleted.

Not trying to discourage you but that's just how the site currently works.

For sources, see What are some online sources to get unabridged Hindu Scriptures or to learn Hinduism?

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .