5

Question A

It asks "Which scripture is the source of a verse A?"

Question B:

This question asks "Which scripture is the source of a verse B and who composed it?"


Now, verse A and B both are part of a same Stotra, with verse A the 1st verse and verse B the 5th verse of a Saraswati Storam (a Hymn), which was composed by Agastya Muni.

So, both these questions will have the same answer, if the Stotra is at all part of some scriptures. (the author part is already answered by me under Q- B, and the OP of Q-A is not asking about author at all)

The answer of both the questions will be just one viz-something like " Yes, it's part of XYZ Purana or some other scripture"

Question: So should they be considered as duplicates? (Question A should be marked as a duplicate of Question B)


UPDATE:

The answer given uses the following questions as examples:

Who is the father of Kumara Swamy and Ganesha?

Who is the husband of Parvati Devi?

Now, these questions are entirely different questions. None can mark them as duplicates.

In this case, however, both the questions are "exactly" the same. The question basically is:

"In which scripture is found Agastya Krutha Saraswati Stotram?"

Assume, there is a Stotram comprised of 50 verses. Are we going to allow 50 such different questions that are just asking, separately, "What is the source of verse 1 to 50?"

7
  • 2
    The questions are different. It is like what is 5+3? and 6+2. They have the same answers but the questions are different. So, they can't be closed. Read this answer from a sister site meta. – Sarvabhouma Jan 17 '18 at 6:16
  • 3
    @Sarvabhouma if 2 different Qns have similar potential answers then they are possible duplicates: Refer the quoted text here. Now there are special cases: Q1 "Who is Subhadra's husband"? Q2 "Who was told Gita by Krishna?". Both answers are "Arjuna". Here Q1 & Q2 are Not duplicates. But if any answer of Q1 covers Q2 as well, then they are duplicates. – iammilind Jan 17 '18 at 9:35
  • 1
    ""In which scripture is found Agastya Krutha Saraswati Stotram?"" Nope. The question is Which scripture has the shloka not the stotram because the questioners do not know that it is a part of Agastya kruta stotram. – Sarvabhouma Jan 17 '18 at 10:35
  • 1
    Is this related to unethical rep earning as well ? – Rakesh Joshi Jan 17 '18 at 10:59
  • 1
    That is discussed here. – Pandya Jan 17 '18 at 12:55
  • 1
    Possible duplicate of What are the rules to be followed while answering two similar questions?. According to that post, Question A and B are duplicates. – iammilind Jan 17 '18 at 13:20
  • Yes, it is @RakeshJoshi See this post: hinduism.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1023/… – Rickross Jan 17 '18 at 14:53
1

When the questions are asking the same or expressing the same meaning with different words and gives the same answer, they can be closed as duplicates.

But here, the questions and verses asked are different. Two questions are asking two different veres. Even though the answer is the same stotra, they can't be closed as exact duplicates. For example, consider this question:

  1. Who is the father of Kumara Swamy and Ganesha?

  2. Who is the husband of Parvati Devi?

No doubt, the answer to both the questions is Shiva but they are not duplicate questions.

An answer from a sister meta site address a similar query.

In general, it is incorrect to dupe close based on the answer. Just because two questions have the same answer does not mean that they are the same question.

Only exception to this rule are canonical questions which are always answered in the same way without a detailed explanation or introduction. For example "Why is this user suspended?". So, those questions can be closed as duplicates.


The edit made by the author of the question makes clearer why they are not duplicates.

People trying to mark the question as a duplicate kindly note the so called Agastya Stotra that is the answer in the other question is NOT the only source of this verse. No point linking this to that since this particular prayer is found in multiple texts including the Bhavabhuti Subhashita.

So, they are not duplicates because the stotra is not the only source. It is found in many other documents.

3
  • 1
    Your linked meta post's answer was greatly written and accurate. Users of this site should learn from linked post :) – Vishvam Jan 17 '18 at 7:25
  • 1
    You have completely ignored the fact that the Qs also are almost similar or even exactly similar. The examples that you're giving in the answer are not relevant here. Those are completely different Qs. – Rickross Jan 17 '18 at 9:21
  • 2
    @Rickross Sure.. you need a reason for a disagreement. The questions I gave are different and not duplicates at all. When a user wants to find father of Ganesha and sees a duplicate linking who is Parvati's husband? How will the closure help? We should see the usefulness for the future users. The questions I linked are relevant and also the examples I gave are very much relevant. – Sarvabhouma Jan 17 '18 at 9:28

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .